Emerging Democratic Majority about this site | contact | search | home 
Emerging Democratic Majority
get the EDM newsletters  Navigation - Sign Up
EDM Newsletter Donkey Rising

« All Trial Heats Are Not Created Equal | Main | Live by the Tax Issue, Die by the Tax Issue? »


April 13, 2004

Republican Analysts Lower the Bar

Here's a recent statement on Bush's approval ratings and what they portend for his re-election from the conservative website RealClearPolitics.com.

As a crude measuring stick for the state of the presidential race, an over 50% job approval for the President should translate into a Bush victory. A 45% - 49% job approval will mean a close race, but I would give President Bush the advantage. A 40% - 44% job approval for the President would translate into a dead heat race, and below 40% and you would have to give the advantage to Kerry.

Oh really? And just what do they base this cheerful assessment on? They don't say, but it is worth noting that this represents a considerable lowering of the bar for Bush (just keep it at 45 or above and even 40-44 isn't so bad!) compared to earlier Republican claims about his approval ratings.

Here's what I had to say back in February of 2003 when Matthew Dowd, pollster for the RNC, was touting 50 percent or above as the magic number for Bush:

....we don't really know an incumbent president at 50 percent can't be defeated. After all, we only have approval rating data from 1948 onwards, so there are a very limited amount of cases to consider -- to be precise, eight, if we restrict our attention to incumbent presidents. Of these eight, none had a rating of exactly 50 percent in July of their election year and the closest was 53 percent. So maybe 53 percent is the magic level (if there is one) -- Dowd's use of the 50 percent level is purely arbitrary and slants the rather thin historical record in Bush's favor. In addition, the president who had this 53 percent rating and was, in fact, reelected (Ronald Reagan in 1984) also had the benefit of a strong economy. So what happens at 53 percent and a weak economy, like Bush currently has? We don't know. And we certainly don't know about 50 percent and a weak economy, the scenario Dowd seems to be trying to cover with his confident historical assertions. Indeed, the closer one looks at Dowd's "50 percent and you're golden" rule for re-electing incumbent presidents, the shakier it looks. What he's trying to pass off as an iron law of history is, in fact, a tendentious reading of a very modest amount of real data.

What goes for Dowd goes double for RealClearPolitics and their attempt to make 45 percent the magic number.

Especially since there's really only one case that falls into the 45-49 percent approval category--where Bush is now--and that's Gerald Ford. And he lost. And there's really never been a 40-44 case (Carter and Bush I were sub-40 guys) so how can they say that such a rating translates into a "dead heat"? It seems more reasonable, if you're going to play this game, to say that a rating in between Ford's and Carter/Bush I's translates into a likely loss, not a tossup.

These guys are just whistling past the graveyard. Their attempts to make up fake historical laws are just designed to (1) paper over the fact that his current approval ratings are more bad than good news for an incumbent president; and (2) give them bogus talking points so that, if Bush falls any farther, they can still claim he's bound to win.

Don't be taken in. They're worried. Real worried.

Posted by Ruy Teixeira at 10:57 PM | link

 



EDM Newsletter


The Incredible Shrinking National Security Gap (Apr 13) By Ruy Teixeira


Oh, Those Liberal College Students! (Apr 12) By Ruy Teixeira


What Does the Public Want on Immigration? (Apr 5) By Ruy Teixeira


Exurbia: The Democrats' Next Frontier (Mar 31) By Ruy Teixeira


2006 Election Outlook: The Macro and the Micro (Mar 30) By Ruy Teixeira


2006 Campaign Watch (Mar 24) By Ruy Teixeira


The Iraq War, Three Years On (Mar 22) By Ruy Teixeira


Will the Real Swingers Please Stand Up? (Mar 22) By Alan Abramowitz


Did the Bin Laden Tape Tip the Election to Bush? (Mar 21) By David Gopoian


The UN: Good Idea, Bad Execution (Mar 16) By Ruy Teixeira


Strong Disapproval Matters (Mar 10) By Alan Abramowitz


The Great Bail-Out (Mar 8) By Ruy Teixeira


Unmarried America: Demographics and Attitudes (Mar 1) By Ruy Teixeira


Weekly analysis of latest public opinion polls by Ruy Teixeira.


» Public Opinion Watch

EDM - The Book


An overview of the influential book.


EDM - The Book

»Read the commentary
» Read articles by John Judis and
Ruy Teixeira

» Buy the book

 
Articles by Ruy Texieira


"The Battle for the Exurbs" by Ruy Teixeira (New York Times)


"Movement Interruptus" by Ruy Teixeira and John B. Judis (American Prospect)


"Old Democrats and the Shock of the New" by Ruy Teixeira (Varieties of Progressivism in America)


"Would Reagan Recognize the GOP?" by John B. Judis (TNR)


"Reality Check" by Ruy Teixeira (contribution to Boston Review forum on "How the Democrats Can Win")


"White Flight: Bush Loses His Base" by John B. Judis and Ruy Teixeira (TNR)


"Don't Mourn, Mobilize" by Ruy Teixeira (American Prospect)


"Newer Democrats" by Ruy Teixeira (The Gadflyer)


"Emerging Democrats" by Ruy Teixeira (Prospect, UK)


"How Kerry Could Beat Bush" by Ruy Teixeira (Salon.com)


Review of Zell Miller's A National Party No More and Stanley Greenberg's The Two Americas by Ruy Teixeira (January-February Washington Monthly)


"The Nonsouthern Strategy" by Cliff Schecter and Ruy Teixeira (February American Prospect)


The Emerging Democratic Majority is now available in paperback. You can buy it here. Read an excerpt from the new afterword here.

Recent Entries

Dems' Game Plan Taking Shape (Jul 3)

GOP '06 Strategy Hinges on Iraq, Terrorism(Jul 2)

LA Times Poll: Dems Pulling Ahead in Congressional Races(Jun 30)

SCOTUS Redistricting Decision and Dems' Future(Jun 29)

GQR Survey Reveals Swing Voter Priorities(Jun 28)

Dems Take Lead in Midwest Bellwether(Jun 27)

Stampede of the Rinos or Ain't Nuthin' the Matter With Kansas(Jun 26)

Can Dems Match GOP Ground Game?(Jun 25)

Confronting the "Cut and Run" Label(Jun 22)

'Mapchanger Attitude' Needed for a Blue America(Jun 21)


Search The Archive
Keyword: 

 
Archives

July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003
July 2003
June 2003


Internet Resources


Blogs

Eric Alterman
Angry Bear
Bull Moose (Marshall Wittmann)
Centerfield
Campaign Confidential (E.J. Kessler)
Juan Cole
Columbia Journalism Review
  Campaign Desk

Joe Conason
Daily Kos
The Decembrist (Mark Schmitt)
Brad DeLong
Democracy Arsenal (Security and
  Peace Institute)

Eschaton
Facing South (Institute for
  Southern Studies)

Gadflyer Fly Trap
GoozNews (Merrill Goozner)
The Left Coaster
LiberalOasis
MyDD (Jerome Armstrong)
Mystery Pollster
NewDonkey (Ed Kilgore)
New Democrat Network
Political Animal (Kevin Drum)
Political State Report
Political Strategy
Political Wire (Taegan Goddard)
Politics1
PolySigh
Radical Middle
The Plank (New Republic)
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo
TPM Cafe
TAPPED (American Prospect)
Think Progress (Center for American Progress)
Third Estate (Publius)
War and Piece (Laura Rozen)
Washington Note (Steve Clemons)
The Yellin Report
Matthew Yglesias

Online Magazines and Digests

BuzzFlash Report
CommonDreams 
Gadflyer
Moving Ideas
Salon
Slate 
Tom Paine

Print Magazine Web Sites

American Prospect
Atlantic Monthly
Blueprint
Boston Review
Dissent
Foreign Policy
London Review of Books
Nation
National Interest
New Left Review
New Republic
New York Review of Books
New Yorker
Policy Review
Prospect (UK)
Public Interest
Washington Monthly
Weekly Standard

Think Tanks

American Enterprise Institute
Brookings Institution
Center for American Progress
Center for Budget and Policy
  Priorities

Center for Economic and Policy
  Research

The Century Foundation
Citizens for Tax Justice
Economic Policy Institute
Financial Markets Center
New America Foundation
Urban Institute

Organizations

America Coming Together
Campaign for America's Future
Democratic Leadership Council
Democratic National Committee
Democrats.com
MoveOn.org
New Democrat Network
Progressive Democrats of America
Third Way


Internet Resources


Recent Polls

ABC News
AEI public opinion studies
American Research Group
Annenberg Election Survey
CBS News
Democracy Corps
Economist/YouGov
Fox News
Gallup
Greenberg Quinlan Rosner
GW Battleground
Harris
Hotline/Westhill Partners
IBD/CSM/TIPP
ICR
Ipsos/Associated Press
Kaiser Family Foundation
Los Angeles Times
Marist College
National Election Studies
Newsweek
Pew Research Center
Phi Delta Kappa education polls
Polling Report
Pollkatz's Pool of Polls
Public Agenda
Program on International Policy
  Attitudes

Quinnipiac University
Rasmussen Reports
RealClear Politics polling data
  roundups

Roper Center presidential approval
  series

Survey USA
Time/SRBI
USA Today
Wall Street Journal/NBC News
Washington Post/ABC News
Zogby

2004 Election Data

CNN election results
CNN NEP exit poll results
Dave Leip's election atlas
Democracy Corps postelection
  survey

Los Angeles Times exit poll
MSNBC NEP exit poll results
New York Times exit poll data
  spreadsheet

New York Times portrait of the
  2004 electorate

WCVI Hispanic exit poll

2002 Election Data

CNN election results
Democracy Corps postelection
  survey

Los Angeles Times California exit poll

2000 Election Data

CNN election results
Dave Leip's election atlas
Democracy Corps postelection
  survey

Los Angeles Times exit poll
New York Times portrait of the 2000
  electorate

VNS exit poll

 

 

 

 

 


 Dialogue Among Dems | The Strategy Center | EDM - The Book | About This Site
 
Contents Copyright © 2003-2004 by Ruy Teixeira
 
Powered by Movable Type 3.11

XML RSS